Drei Paar Hände rund um einen neu gepflanzten Baum

Why is planting trees not always a good idea?

Planting trees is often seen as an effective way to combat climate change, as trees absorb CO2 from the air and produce oxygen. While planting can certainly have a positive effect on the environment, there are some factors to consider that show what a complex matter this is and why it is not always a good idea.

What should be considered when planting trees?

First of all, it is important to note that it is not always a sustainable solution. Planting trees in areas that are not designated for forest planting can lead to ecological problems. Introducing trees in non-native areas can affect biodiversity and encourage invasive species that can displace native plants and animals. In addition, trees can prove impractical due to their size and their needs for water and nutrients, and can become a tangible problem if not properly maintained.

Another important consideration is the type of trees planted. Not all are equally effective at absorbing CO2 and producing oxygen. Some have a higher CO2 absorption rate than others and again some produce more oxygen than others. It is important to select trees that are capable of producing the maximum environmental benefit.

In addition, climatic conditions in certain regions may mean that planted trees are not able to establish themselves or grow effectively. If trees are planted in areas prone to drought or flooding, they may wither or die and eventually become another environmental burden.

Another factor that should be considered is the space required by trees. It may be that planting trees can cause agricultural land or pasture to conflict with other land uses. This can lead to problems such as loss of land, competition for water and nutrients, and difficulties in harvesting crops.

Meanwhile, many companies use tree planting for their marketing purposes, e.g. "every product = a new tree". What sounds catchy and nice at first can quickly turn out to be greenwashing if the company in question does not transparently explain who plants which trees, when, where and how. In addition, it is sometimes difficult for the companies themselves to understand what is actually happening. After all, there are now many projects and providers who take over the planting for them and are not particularly transparent about it. In any case the points mentioned above should be clear to everyone involved. In the best case, one simply supports a scientifically accompanied reforestation project in which the goal, purpose and continuation of the project are clear.

Quite apart from planting trees, there are other ways to reduce the impact of climate change. Below we present some alternative methods to combat climate change:

Renewable energies

Using renewable energies such as solar energy, wind energy, hydropower or geothermal energy is an important way to combat climate change. By using renewable energy, the amount of greenhouse gases released during energy production is significantly reduced.

Energy efficiency

Another way to combat climate change is to increase energy efficiency. This can be achieved through the use of energy efficient appliances and the implementation of energy conservation measures in buildings and industrial facilities.

Sustainable agriculture

Sustainable agriculture is an important factor in combating climate change. By using sustainable farming methods such as regenerative agriculture, the soil can store carbon and thus reduce the release of greenhouse gases.

Circular economy

A circular economy helps to reduce resource consumption and thus reduce environmental impact. By reusing products and using recycled materials, the generation of greenhouse gases is reduced.


Transport is a significant factor in the generation of greenhouse gases. By using low-emission vehicles such as electric cars or by promoting public transport and bicycle infrastructure, CO2 emissions can be significantly reduced.


Overall, tree planting can be an important measure to combat climate change, but the above factors should be taken into account to ensure that it is a sustainable solution. It is important to plant suitable trees in suitable areas and ensure that they are adequately maintained to maximise their impact. In addition, there are many alternative methods to combat climate change away from tree planting. It is important that we opt for a combination of different approaches in order to make an effective contribution to climate protection together.

Back to magazine

Discover our Nirvana soaps